CHAMISA BLASTS ED OVER CORONAVIRUS

MDC president Nelson Chamisa has blasted his nemesis,
President Emmerson Mnangagwa for his lackadaisical approach at handling the
coronavirus, saying he should consider locking down the country’s borders to
avoid the spread of the deadly virus.

Ch…

MDC president Nelson Chamisa has blasted his nemesis, President Emmerson Mnangagwa for his lackadaisical approach at handling the coronavirus, saying he should consider locking down the country’s borders to avoid the spread of the deadly virus. Chamisa also challenged Mnangagwa to go into self-isolation after his trip to Namibia last Friday to attend the inauguration of Namibian President

FRACAS: Woman steals towels & plates from hotel, husband takes the stolen property back to the hotel

A hairdresser at Flamboyant Hotel was last week sentenced to 12 months imprisonment by magistrate Patience Madondo after her vindictive husband exposed her for stealing hotel towels, bed sheets, cutlery and crockery. Magistrate Madondo set aside four m…

A hairdresser at Flamboyant Hotel was last week sentenced to 12 months imprisonment by magistrate Patience Madondo after her vindictive husband exposed her for stealing hotel towels, bed sheets, cutlery and crockery. Magistrate Madondo set aside four months from the 12 and wholly suspended the remaining eight months on condition that Kadambu performed 280 hours […]

1 446 tonnes of maize intended for the poor DISAPPEAR: Senior Zanu PF official confirms

In a shocking revelation, 1 446 tonnes of maize intended for the poor and grown under a welfare winter maize crop supported by Tongaat Hullet and Government have gone missing in Chiredzi, a senior Zanu PF official has confirmed. The winter crop is grow…

In a shocking revelation, 1 446 tonnes of maize intended for the poor and grown under a welfare winter maize crop supported by Tongaat Hullet and Government have gone missing in Chiredzi, a senior Zanu PF official has confirmed. The winter crop is grown by Masvingo Province Development Trust (MDT) on 326 hectares of land […]

Man drinks rat poison after wife insulted him saying he was not as good as her boyfriend in bed

A teacher at Gunura Secondary School in Buhera has died after drinking rat poison allegedly because his wife told him that he did not perform in bed as well as her boyfriend. Sources told The Mirror that Ganga who was on leave at the time of the commis…

A teacher at Gunura Secondary School in Buhera has died after drinking rat poison allegedly because his wife told him that he did not perform in bed as well as her boyfriend. Sources told The Mirror that Ganga who was on leave at the time of the commission of the suicide left a note stating […]

Covid-19: Nelson Chamisa challenges Mnangagwa who recently visited Namibia to go into self-isolation

MDC president Nelson Chamisa has blasted his nemesis, President Emmerson Mnangagwa for his lackadaisical approach at handling the coronavirus, saying he should consider locking down the country’s borders to avoid the spread of the deadly virus. C…

MDC president Nelson Chamisa has blasted his nemesis, President Emmerson Mnangagwa for his lackadaisical approach at handling the coronavirus, saying he should consider locking down the country’s borders to avoid the spread of the deadly virus. Chamisa also challenged Mnangagwa to go into self-isolation after his trip to Namibia last Friday to attend the inauguration […]

12 months in jail for people who gather in crowds of more than 50 people, govt introduces new law

PRESIDENT Mnangagwa yesterday mourned journalist Zororo Makamba who became the first Zimbabwean to succumb to Covid-19 and announced a raft of measures to contain the virus. He ordered the closure of all borders to human traffic and banned non-essentia…

PRESIDENT Mnangagwa yesterday mourned journalist Zororo Makamba who became the first Zimbabwean to succumb to Covid-19 and announced a raft of measures to contain the virus. He ordered the closure of all borders to human traffic and banned non-essential travel except for the movement of cargo. The Government also promulgated Statutory Instrument (SI) 77 of […]

Coronavirus: Group of 42 tourists from 11 countries arrives in Victoria Falls

TOURISM players in Victoria Falls yesterday implored Government to close borders especially for travellers from high-risk countries to prevent the spread of coronavirus. This comes as some countries have imposed travel restrictions while airlines have …

TOURISM players in Victoria Falls yesterday implored Government to close borders especially for travellers from high-risk countries to prevent the spread of coronavirus. This comes as some countries have imposed travel restrictions while airlines have also suspended flights. Yesterday panic gripped Victoria Falls when a group of 42 tourists from 11 countries arrived in the […]

MUST READ: President Mnangagwa announces sweeping measures & bans to stop the spread of coronavirus

PRESIDENT Mnangagwa last night announced sweeping measures and bans to stop the spread of coronavirus (Covid-19) which recorded its first death yesterday afternoon. The measures include an immediate ban on gatherings around night clubs, bars, beerhalls…

PRESIDENT Mnangagwa last night announced sweeping measures and bans to stop the spread of coronavirus (Covid-19) which recorded its first death yesterday afternoon. The measures include an immediate ban on gatherings around night clubs, bars, beerhalls, movie houses, swimming pools, gymnasiums and sporting activities until further notice. With immediate effect, all the country’s borders have […]

LATEST: Zupco hikes bus fares by 100 percent (SEE NEW FARES)

Zupco bus and kombi fares doubled yesterday to cover rising costs, but are still well below those charged by independent operators. The last increase was in September last year. Zupco bus fares to most high density suburbs will now be $2 and to more di…

Zupco bus and kombi fares doubled yesterday to cover rising costs, but are still well below those charged by independent operators. The last increase was in September last year. Zupco bus fares to most high density suburbs will now be $2 and to more distant urban destinations, such as Chitungwiza, are now $3 compared to […]

Zimbabwe government’s land for compensation offer is misleading 

Widespread reports that former Zimbabwean commercial farmers can now apply to repossess their land under new regulations gazetted by the government, Statutory Instrument (SI) 62 of 2020, published on March 6, 2020 are misleading and provide false hope to dispossessed farmers, many of whom are destitute. Source: Zimbabwe government’s land for compensation offer is misleading […]

The post Zimbabwe government’s land for compensation offer is misleading  appeared first on Zimbabwe Situation.

Widespread reports that former Zimbabwean commercial farmers can now apply to repossess their land under new regulations gazetted by the government, Statutory Instrument (SI) 62 of 2020, published on March 6, 2020 are misleading and provide false hope to dispossessed farmers, many of whom are destitute.

Source: Zimbabwe government’s land for compensation offer is misleading – The Zimbabwean

Ben Freeth

The reality is that the new rules only apply to ‘indigenous’ farmers who lost their land during the fast-track land reform programme, or to foreign-owned farms that were theoretically protected under Bilateral Investment Promotion and Protection Agreements (BIPPAs) and Bilateral Investment Treaties (BITs).

While the regulations do not define the meaning of the term ‘indigenous’, the government has consistently referred to ‘black’ Zimbabweans exclusively as ‘indigenous’ persons.

This is despite the fact that the standard definition of ‘indigenous’ applies to persons born and residing in a particular place or region – and is not exclusive to a particular race, gender or ethnicity.

A significant number of the dispossessed white farmers were born in Zimbabwe and many were second, third or even fourth generation who knew no other home. Like other dedicated farmers around the world they were committed to investing in their farms, ploughing back their profits into the land and successfully building the agro-based economy.

A legal expert who handled numerous cases involving the unilateral take-over of commercial farms from February 2000 onwards informed SADC Tribunal Rights Watch that he is aware of only three court cases involving two ‘black’ and one ‘brown’ Zimbabwean holders of land who were forced off their properties out of the approximately 4,500 original farmers.

However, Lands, Agriculture, Water and Rural Resettlement Minister Perrance Shiri said on March 20, 2020 that a total of 440 farms belonging to ‘indigenous’ people had been acquired under the Land Reform Programme.

He said that 350 of the farmers were still on the acquired land while 90 farms had resettled farmers.

Bilateral Investment Promotion and Protection Agreements

With respect to BIPPAs and BITs, the new legislation suggests that the government will – for the first time – honour its promises and obligations under international customary law to respect Bilateral Protection of Investment properties.

Prior to this, a blind eye has been turned to these international agreements, despite the rulings made by the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID) – part of the World Bank Group – in the Dutch Farmers’ case (2009) and in the Von Pezold judgment (2015). Both judgments upheld Zimbabwe’s obligation to make prompt, efficient payment in a currency of the claimant’s choice.

The reason that BIPPA and BIT-protected properties are now being considered for compensation is that the bankrupt government needs the support of foreign donors and international lending institutions.

However, the legislation does not fulfil the demands of the Zimbabwe Democracy and Economic Recovery Act (ZDERA), instituted by the US government regarding its demands for re-engagement.

The purpose and intent of this SI 62 is to offer an alternative to compensation. It does not offer land and compensation, despite the mass-scale destruction that has taken place on the former commercial farms and the ruinous loss of income to dispossessed farmers over the past two decades.

Furthermore, it also provides that the alienation or restoration “of a piece of acquired agricultural land comprising only part of a farm to a qualifying applicant in terms of these regulations shall be in final settlement of any claim for compensation to the extent that the application is successful.”

It is important to note that putting a lid or cap on all compensation claims if a person gets back his title is both wrong in principle and is grossly unfair.

The reason the commercial farm land identified in this process was never legally transferred was that it had been taken forcibly, often violently or under duress from the farm owner, instead of being sold legitimately to the government for possible resettlement.

Legally, the process of compulsory acquisition demands an obligation from the government to pay prompt and fair compensation. According to international law, if this does not take place, the sale or takeover must be reversed.

Reinstated indigenous, BIPPA and BIT owners remain unprotected by legislation

Section 293 of the Constitution stipulates that “an Act of Parliament must prescribe procedures for alienation and reallocation of agricultural land by the State….”

Contrary to the implications of SI 62, there is no requisite legislation – or change in legislation – that protects reinstated land owners in all three categories: ‘indigenous’ or citizens of either a BIPPA or BIT country from being targeted again by the same legislation that led to their initial dispossession.

With regard to every BIPPA that the Zimbabwe government has signed but failed to adhere to, it is important to note that these agreements have not been incorporated into Zimbabwe’s domestic laws – a process known as “domestication” – so that they become legally binding and enforceable.

Without an Act in place for the BIPPA and BIT agreements, the government cannot – according to Zimbabwean law – offer compensation to these foreign investors.

However, should farmers turn down the offer of land in lieu of compensation, the alternative offered by government of a payment made over time and in the worthless, ever devaluating RTGS (Zimbabwe) dollar is equally unacceptable.

“Regrettably,  this piece of misleading legislation is another attempt at window dressing to make it appear that the Zimbabwe government is going to return farms to their owners and re-establish property rights – but this is not the case,” said Ben Freeth, spokesperson for advocacy group SADC Tribunal Rights Watch.

“More than 40 years after independence, one would legitimately expect that Section 56 of our Constitution concerning ‘equality and non-discrimination’ would apply with full force. The reality is that so-called ‘indigenous’ Zimbabweans have more rights than ‘white’ citizens who have been deprived of their homes, businesses and livelihoods, as well as compensation for their losses,” said Freeth.

Additionally, citizens of selected countries with investment treaties with Zimbabwe have more rights – according to the stipulations of the BIPPAs and BITs – than ‘white’ Zimbabweans citizens whose rights should be protected under the Constitution.

“As such, this legislation is discriminatory,” Freeth said. “It also goes against the Southern African Development Community (SADC) Treaty and the landmark Campbell Case judgment of November 2008 in the SADC Tribunal, the regional human rights court.”

The Tribunal held that the Zimbabwe government violated the organisation’s treaty by denying access to the courts and engaging in racial discrimination against white farmers whose farms had been confiscated under the land reform programme in Zimbabwe.

“Discriminatory laws can quickly lead to institutionalising racial discrimination. We need to do everything we possibly can to test these counterproductive laws against our Constitution and international law,” said Freeth.

“Furthermore, the government cannot convince international investors from countries like the UK  ̶  who are discriminated against because there’s no bilateral investment treaty  ̶  that Zimbabwe is a secure investment destination when it fails to respect the rights of both international investors and its own citizens,” he concluded.

The post Zimbabwe government’s land for compensation offer is misleading  appeared first on Zimbabwe Situation.