HARARE – A public reprimand by Deputy Chief Secretary to the President and Cabinet George Charamba has intensified scrutiny of the limits of executive authority in Zimbabwe, after he accused former Local Government permanent secretary Tafadzwa Muguti of exceeding his powers by attempting to restrict media coverage of traditional courts.
Charamba’s intervention followed President Emmerson Mnangagwa’s decision to remove Muguti from office less than two months after his appointment. Although the Government did not give an official reason for the dismissal, the latest criticism has placed the former official’s directive on media access at the centre of renewed debate about constitutional accountability.
Writing on X, Charamba argued that customary law courts form part of Zimbabwe’s judicial system and that executive officials cannot independently determine how their proceedings should be covered by journalists.
“Chief’s courts are part of the court system of the country. They are part of the judiciary, and no member of the executive branch can set rules for those courts without breaching the doctrine of separation of powers,” Charamba wrote.
He added that decisions on whether proceedings should be open to journalists or held in camera belonged to the judicial officers presiding over individual cases.
“No govt official can bar the media from covering court proceedings; only judicial officers in charge of those proceedings can,” he said, describing Muguti’s position as being “out of order”.
The remarks, reported by ZiFM Stereo, represent a significant public criticism of an official who had recently occupied a senior position in the Ministry of Local Government and Public Works. They also provide a clearer indication of the institutional disagreement surrounding Muguti’s attempt to regulate media coverage, although the Presidency has not formally identified the directive as the reason for his dismissal.
Constitutional boundaries and judicial independence
Zimbabwe’s Constitution provides a legal basis for the distinction Charamba was making. Section 162 vests judicial authority in the courts, explicitly including customary law courts, while Section 163 recognises persons presiding over those courts as members of the judiciary.
Section 164 further protects judicial independence and prohibits the State and its institutions from interfering with the functioning of the courts.
The constitutional framework does not mean that every court proceeding must be filmed or broadcast without restriction. Lawful limitations may apply, including decisions by judicial officers to protect privacy, confidentiality and the proper administration of justice. The central issue raised by Charamba is who has the legal authority to impose those restrictions.
That distinction matters because a permanent secretary, despite holding considerable administrative responsibility, does not automatically acquire judicial powers through appointment to an executive office.
The controversy also highlights the need to distinguish between the administrative oversight of traditional institutions and the adjudicative functions exercised by customary law courts. Government may have responsibilities under legislation governing traditional leadership, but those responsibilities do not confer unrestricted authority over judicial proceedings.
Why institutional consistency matters to business
For Zimbabwe’s economy, the dispute extends beyond the relationship between government officials and journalists. It raises a wider question about the predictability of public institutions and the boundaries within which administrative decisions are made.
Investors assess more than tax rates, exchange-rate stability and access to infrastructure. They also consider the reliability of legal institutions, the enforceability of contracts, the protection of property rights and the consistency of government decisions.
The Zimbabwe Mail news desk notes that institutional credibility is an economic asset. Where administrative officials issue directives that are subsequently challenged on constitutional grounds, businesses and investors can face uncertainty over which rules apply, who has authority to enforce them and whether decisions will remain in force.
This is particularly relevant to property development, construction, commercial agriculture and businesses operating in rural communities, where customary law institutions and traditional leadership can play important roles in resolving local disputes.
Customary courts are often closer to communities than formal judicial institutions and can provide an accessible avenue for resolving disputes under customary law. Their legitimacy, however, depends on operating within the Constitution and the applicable legislation, while respecting the rights of the people appearing before them.
Transparency is equally important. Media reporting can help expose misconduct, improve public understanding of proceedings and strengthen accountability. At the same time, responsible reporting must respect lawful restrictions protecting vulnerable parties and confidential information.
A test for the incoming administration
Muguti’s departure leaves incoming permanent secretary Addmore Pazvakavambwa with the broader challenge of restoring confidence in the ministry’s administrative processes.
The ministry has significant responsibilities covering local authorities, urban planning, housing, public infrastructure and service delivery. Its decisions affect the operating environment for businesses, property owners, developers and millions of residents.
The recent controversy reinforces the importance of clearly distinguishing executive policy-making from the independent exercise of judicial authority. It also demonstrates why public officials need to understand the constitutional limits of their mandates before issuing directives that affect institutions outside their direct administrative control.
For Mnangagwa’s administration, the more consequential issue is not simply the departure of one permanent secretary. It is whether government institutions can demonstrate that authority is exercised consistently, lawfully and with sufficient accountability to protect public confidence.
Zimbabwe’s investment ambitions will require more than promotional campaigns and policy announcements. They will depend on institutions capable of providing predictable rules, respecting constitutional boundaries and applying the law consistently.
The post Charamba Rebukes Muguti Over Chiefs’ Courts Media Restrictions appeared first on The Zimbabwe Mail.