How Zimbabwe’s government turned international condemnation into political ammunition

International pressure intended to encourage democratic reform can sometimes strengthen the very governments it seeks to hold to account, according to new research from The University of Manchester. The study examined Zimbabwe’s decision to withdraw from the Commonwealth in December 2003, finding that the move was driven less by a rejection of international institutions in […]

The post How Zimbabwe’s government turned international condemnation into political ammunition appeared first on Zimbabwe Situation.

International pressure intended to encourage democratic reform can sometimes strengthen the very governments it seeks to hold to account, according to new research from The University of Manchester.

The study examined Zimbabwe’s decision to withdraw from the Commonwealth in December 2003, finding that the move was driven less by a rejection of international institutions in principle than by the ruling party’s determination to remain in power.

Why Zimbabwe left the Commonwealth

Zimbabwe was suspended from the Commonwealth in 2002 amid concerns about its presidential election and democratic standards. When the suspension continued following a Commonwealth meeting in Abuja, Nigeria, in December 2003, President Robert Mugabe’s government announced its withdrawal.

But the research, by Dr. Arthur Shirichena of The University of Manchester and Pofela Ndzozi of Lupane State University in Zimbabwe, argues that withdrawal was a strategic political choice.

The authors examined documentary evidence, including Commonwealth and Zimbabwean government records, parliamentary material and contemporary reporting, to understand the decisions behind the country’s departure.

They argue that meeting the conditions for reinstatement—including improvements to elections, media freedom and judicial independence, as well as reductions in political violence—risked weakening ZANU-PF’s control.

The government continued to pursue a return to the Commonwealth while that appeared possible on terms it could accept. Once the Abuja outcome made that prospect less realistic, leaving became a way to protect its domestic position rather than accept reforms that might undermine it.

Turning criticism into a defense of sovereignty

The study finds that the government also used international criticism to reinforce its political narrative at home.

By presenting the dispute as an attack on Zimbabwe’s sovereignty and its anticolonial liberation struggle, ZANU-PF could portray external pressure as foreign interference. The government could also cast domestic opponents who called for reform as aligned with outside interests.

This helped the ruling party mobilize political support and shift responsibility for Zimbabwe’s international isolation onto its critics.

The authors argue that this strategy served the interests of the ruling coalition, even if withdrawal reduced Zimbabwe’s diplomatic access and standing. The government’s political survival, rather than the country’s wider national interest, was the central consideration.

Lessons for international pressure today

The research highlights a challenge for governments and international organizations seeking to encourage democratic change: diplomatic isolation does not automatically lead to reform.

Where leaders see international demands as a threat to their hold on power, they may reject those demands, challenge the legitimacy of their critics or use the dispute to rally domestic support.

The authors caution that the Zimbabwe case does not provide a universal explanation for how governments respond to international pressure, but say it shows why the likely domestic political consequences of diplomatic action need to be considered alongside its intended goals.

“When a government sees the demand for reforms as a threat to its hold on power, it may find it more useful to portray external criticism as an attack on national sovereignty than to comply. The challenge for the international community is to understand how pressure will play out in domestic politics, rather than assume that isolation will necessarily bring reform,” said Shirichena.

The research was published in The Round Table journal.

Source: How Zimbabwe’s government turned international condemnation into political ammunition

The post How Zimbabwe’s government turned international condemnation into political ammunition appeared first on Zimbabwe Situation.

Mnangagwa wins the latest round of Zimbabwe’s succession battle

ZANU-PF’s conference strengthened the president’s position, but Chiwenga’s defiance signals that the struggle for power is far from over. Published on 23 October 2026 in ISS Today By Peter Fabricius Consultant, ISS Pretoria The intense power struggle that has been simmering between Zimbabwe’s President Emmerson Mnangagwa and First Vice-President Constantino Chiwenga resurfaced at last week’s […]

The post Mnangagwa wins the latest round of Zimbabwe’s succession battle appeared first on Zimbabwe Situation.

ZANU-PF’s conference strengthened the president’s position, but Chiwenga’s defiance signals that the struggle for power is far from over.

Published on 23 October 2026 in ISS Today By Peter Fabricius
Consultant, ISS Pretoria

The intense power struggle that has been simmering between Zimbabwe’s President Emmerson Mnangagwa and First Vice-President Constantino Chiwenga resurfaced at last week’s Zimbabwe African National Union-Patriotic Front (ZANU-PF) annual conference in Chinhoyi.

The media made much about Chiwenga’s speech in which he appeared to warn Mnangagwa that he was in danger of precipitating a repetition of the events of November 2017. Chiwenga, then military chief, led a coup that toppled Robert Mugabe and replaced him with Mnangagwa, ushering in the so-called Second Republic.

‘What led to the emergence of the Second Republic?’ Chiwenga asked. ‘It emerged from correcting the rot that was prevailing. Are we not repeating the same mistakes? That is the question we should be asking ourselves.’

He called for a ‘brutal and honest self-appraisal,’ including asking if the congress resolutions were ‘truly coming from the people.’ He had already raised eyebrows by apparently boycotting a conference ball in honour of Mnangagwa, and the funeral of the mega-rich Mnangagwa crony businessman Wicknell Chivayo, who recently died in a helicopter crash.

In apparent response to those moves, Mnangagwa warned his unnamed – but clearly implied – enemies, at a preparatory central committee meeting, against behaving like ‘demons.’

Chiwenga’s address caused a national buzz. But did it ultimately make a difference? Seemingly not in the short term, at least.

Constantino Chiwenga appeared to warn that Emmerson Mnangagwa risked repeating the events of November 2017

The resolutions Chiwenga didn’t like basically aligned ZANU-PF’s constitution with the Constitution of Zimbabwe Amendment (No. 3) Bill, 2026 – CAB3. This effectively allowed Mnangagwa’s presidential term to be extended from 2028 when it was constitutionally meant to expire, until 2030, by lengthening the electoral cycle from five to seven years. It also replaced the directly elected presidency with one indirectly elected by Parliament.

The conference resolutions at Chinhoyi moved the party’s next elective congress from 2027 to 2029, kept Mnangagwa on as party leader until 2030, and resolved he should be the sole, uncontested presidential candidate at the 2029 congress, to lead ZANU-PF in 2030.

This was all anathema to Chiwenga, for whom, it is widely believed, Mnangagwa promised to step aside in 2028 when Chiwenga helped him oust Mugabe.

Bulawayo mayor David Coltart, a seasoned opposition leader, told ISS Today: ‘What I and what we don’t know is what support Chiwenga has.’ This is the critical question everyone is asking.

He said Mnangagwa had effectively neutralised much of Chiwenga’s military support by, for example, bringing his successor as Zimbabwe Defence Forces commander, Philip Valerio Sibanda, into the ZANU-PF Politburo and ‘kicking upstairs’ army commander Lieutenant-General Anselem Nhamo Sanyatwe. He appointed Sanyatwe as Minister of Sport, Recreation, Arts and Culture – a harmless portfolio.

Yet Coltart also believes Chiwenga would not have been so strident in his comments at the conference had he not still had the support of key elements in the military.

Constantino Chiwenga’s speech got the country talking, but the very changes he was trying to stop were adopted

Coltart believes Chivayo’s sudden death was a serious blow to Mnangagwa, who had used him as a conduit to buy patronage and support – not only domestically, but in the region, with leaders like South Africa’s Cyril Ramaphosa, Eswatini’s King Mswati III, Tanzania’s Samia Suluhu Hassan and Kenya’s William Ruto.

Coltart also noted that Mnangagwa was weakening physically and mentally, presenting himself as 84 though widely believed to be 88 – and so would be 92 if he ran again for office in 2030.

He said if Mnangagwa did run again in 2030, he would confront even more strongly the same constitutional obstacles he and the party had glossed over in CAB3, including that extending presidential term limits required a popular referendum.

‘I think that this situation is becoming extremely problematic. This is just the beginning of a very serious, intense power struggle.’

Zimbabwean journalist and commentator Hopewell Chin’ono, though, believes Mnangagwa clearly out-manoeuvred Chiwenga at the ZANU-PF conference and more generally. He noted on X that Chiwenga had succeeded in blocking the resolutions prolonging Mnangagwa’s term in ZANU-PF’s Politburo and had delivered ‘a rock star speech at the conference.’

‘But the real question is this: did he win anything?’ He thought not. Chin’ono told ISS Today that Chiwenga’s success in the Politburo showed he had influence, but Mnangagwa had overridden the Politburo by getting the resolutions presented from the floor and passed at the conference, which is a higher decision-making body.

Chiwenga’s speech got the media and the country talking, ‘but it earned him nothing, because the very changes he was trying to stop were adopted,’ he posted on X.

Many Zimbabweans, left without an opposition to believe in, are now rallying behind Constantino Chiwenga

However, Chin’ono also says for Chiwenga, defeated politically, the only remaining leverage is the military. ‘If the army is behind him and willing to act, that is his saving grace. Without it, he is finished,’ he says, while adding that a coup is unlikely but cannot be discounted.

‘Nobody knows how much of the military he still has influence over after Mnangagwa removed his allies from there,’ he told ISS Today.

What does this mean for ordinary Zimbabweans not on the gravy train?

As Chin’ono noted on X, many Zimbabweans, left without an opposition to believe in (largely because it has been crushed by ZANU-PF) are now rallying behind Chiwenga ‘as the only man who can end President Mnangagwa’s rule.’

Zimbabweans ‘are mere spectators to a battle raging inside ZANU-PF. Spectators, and nothing more.’

Intelwatch Director Piers Pigou largely agreed, in an interview with ISS Today, characterising the rivalry between the two men as ‘an endless repetitive saga. Chiwenga’s messaging is important, as many who are not in the Mnangagwa camp are not impressed. But they remain in ZANU-PF. It is one big corrupt club, with varying shades of grubbiness.

‘Ultimately, neither [serves] more than partisan interests. Chiwenga is trying to appear more benign … but can he really be trusted?’

Indeed. For ordinary Zimbabweans, the prospects are not encouraging. Either an indefinite continuation of the same debilitating Mnangagwa leadership, or another perilous upheaval with the same basic outcome, more ZANU-PF misgovernance.

Many Zimbabweans and others naively pinned their hopes on Mnangagwa when he ousted Mugabe in 2017, a lesson worth remembering.

Source: Mnangagwa wins the latest round of Zimbabwe’s succession battle | ISS Africa

The post Mnangagwa wins the latest round of Zimbabwe’s succession battle appeared first on Zimbabwe Situation.

Witchcraft shocks Chief Neromwe: They killed her with lightning then dug her grave and stole items she was buried with

Witchcraft Fears Grip Chief Neromwe After Lightning Victim’s Grave is Dug Up Residents of Mangoya, under Chief Neromwe in Chiredzi in Masvingo province, were left distressed after a woman’s grave was found open, with the coffin exposed and some of the …

Witchcraft Fears Grip Chief Neromwe After Lightning Victim’s Grave is Dug Up Residents of Mangoya, under Chief Neromwe in Chiredzi in Masvingo province, were left distressed after a woman’s grave was found open, with the coffin exposed and some of the belongings buried with her missing. Police identified the grave as belonging to Chenai Mahusane, […]

The post Witchcraft shocks Chief Neromwe: They killed her with lightning then dug her grave and stole items she was buried with first appeared on My Zimbabwe News.

‘Greedy’ armed robbers caught and arrested during cash-heist after raiding same company 3 times in 1 day

Four face court over Bulawayo robbery spree after company hit 3 times in one afternoon Four men have appeared in court accused of carrying out 3 armed robberies at a Bulawayo company in a single afternoon, threatening workers with pistols and taking ca…

Four face court over Bulawayo robbery spree after company hit 3 times in one afternoon Four men have appeared in court accused of carrying out 3 armed robberies at a Bulawayo company in a single afternoon, threatening workers with pistols and taking cash and Chinese currency. The accused are Bobby Juwawu, 36, of Hillside in […]

The post ‘Greedy’ armed robbers caught and arrested during cash-heist after raiding same company 3 times in 1 day first appeared on My Zimbabwe News.

Grade 2 pupil beaten to death at School… ‘Kung-Fu expert’ inmate thoroughly assaults another prisoner in jail

A seven-year-old pupil, Anotida Makoto, died after a fight with another child of the same age at Zengenene Primary School in Murewa, police have confirmed. The incident happened on Friday, October 23, 2026, on the school grounds in Mashonaland East Pro…

A seven-year-old pupil, Anotida Makoto, died after a fight with another child of the same age at Zengenene Primary School in Murewa, police have confirmed. The incident happened on Friday, October 23, 2026, on the school grounds in Mashonaland East Province. Makoto reportedly collapsed and lost consciousness after the altercation. He was taken to St […]

The post Grade 2 pupil beaten to death at School… ‘Kung-Fu expert’ inmate thoroughly assaults another prisoner in jail first appeared on My Zimbabwe News.