Zimbabwe Leads African Stock Markets in 2026 With 71% Gain

HARARE — Zimbabwe has emerged as Africa’s strongest-performing equity market in local-currency terms in 2026, recording a reported year-to-date gain of 71% by mid-October, as renewed investor interest in African shares highlights changing perceptions of risk, economic stability and opportunities across the continent. The performance places Zimbabwe ahead of Tanzania, Ghana, Uganda and Nigeria in […]

The post Zimbabwe Leads African Stock Markets in 2026 With 71% Gain appeared first on The Zimbabwe Mail.

HARARE — Zimbabwe has emerged as Africa’s strongest-performing equity market in local-currency terms in 2026, recording a reported year-to-date gain of 71% by mid-October, as renewed investor interest in African shares highlights changing perceptions of risk, economic stability and opportunities across the continent.

The performance places Zimbabwe ahead of Tanzania, Ghana, Uganda and Nigeria in a comparative ranking of ten African equity markets circulated this week, providing a striking indication of the recovery in domestic share valuations.

The figures, supplied in a Wednesday market comparison, show Tanzania advancing 66%, Uganda 63%, Ghana 62% and Nigeria 59%, while the regional BRVM exchange serving several West African economies gained 55%.

Rwanda, Tunisia, Kenya and Egypt also registered positive performances, suggesting that the rally has extended beyond a handful of major African financial centres.

However, the comparison also reveals an important distinction between nominal local-currency appreciation and investment returns measured in US dollars.

Nigeria reportedly delivered approximately 75% in dollar terms by mid-October, demonstrating how currency performance can significantly alter international comparisons.

For Zimbabwe, the 71% advance represents a notable headline achievement, but its broader economic significance depends on the index used, exchange-rate movements, trading liquidity and the extent to which rising share prices reflect improvements in underlying corporate earnings.

Zimbabwe leads African equity gains

The supplied market figures place Zimbabwe at the top of the selected African exchanges, with gains considerably exceeding those recorded in several larger and more internationally accessible markets.

Africa’s leading equity market performances in 2026

Market Reported year-to-date gain
Zimbabwe +71%
Tanzania +66%
Uganda +63%
Ghana +62%
Nigeria +59%
BRVM — West Africa +55%
Rwanda +45%
Tunisia +39%
Kenya +29%
Egypt +25%

Source: Market comparison supplied for Wednesday’s report. Returns are presented as reported local-market gains and have not been independently reconciled to a common currency, index methodology or closing date.

Source: Market comparison supplied for Wednesday’s report. Returns are presented as reported local-market gains and have not been independently reconciled to a common currency, index methodology or closing date.

The ranking illustrates the strength of African equity markets during a period in which investors have increasingly differentiated between countries according to domestic economic reforms, corporate profitability and currency conditions.

Zimbabwe’s position is particularly noteworthy given the country’s long history of exchange-rate instability, limited access to international capital and structural constraints affecting domestic investment.

Nevertheless, strong equity performance does not necessarily mean that an economy has achieved an equivalent rate of growth.

Stock market indices measure changes in the prices of listed securities, whereas economic growth reflects changes in the production of goods and services.

The distinction is especially important in economies where inflation, currency movements and limited market liquidity can have a disproportionate influence on nominal asset prices.

Monetary stability reshapes investment expectations

Zimbabwe’s recent economic policy direction has placed greater emphasis on monetary discipline, exchange-rate management and the gradual restoration of confidence in the domestic financial system.

The Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe’s efforts to stabilise the Zimbabwe Gold currency, commonly known as ZiG, have become central to the government’s broader economic strategy.

Greater predictability in monetary conditions can improve the ability of businesses to plan investment, price goods and manage working capital.

For equity investors, such conditions can also make future corporate earnings easier to assess.

However, the domestic equity market continues to operate within a predominantly US-dollarised economy, creating complications for companies raising capital and investors evaluating returns.

The Zimbabwe Stock Exchange trades in local currency, while the Victoria Falls Stock Exchange provides a US-dollar-denominated trading platform.

This distinction matters because gains recorded on the ZSE cannot be directly compared with dollar-denominated returns without accounting for exchange-rate changes.

An investor whose portfolio rises substantially in ZiG terms may record a different return when the investment is converted into US dollars.

Equally, a relatively modest gain in a market whose currency strengthens against the dollar may produce a superior international return.

Zimbabwe’s reported 71% advance must therefore be understood within the context of its domestic monetary system rather than interpreted automatically as a 71% increase in dollar wealth.

Nigeria demonstrates the importance of currency-adjusted returns

Nigeria’s performance offers an instructive comparison.

Although the country’s reported local-market gain of 59% trails Zimbabwe and Tanzania, its estimated US-dollar return of approximately 75% places it ahead of the other markets in the supplied comparison on that measure.

The difference illustrates the importance of exchange-rate movements in determining returns for international investors.

A stock market can perform strongly in domestic terms but deliver weaker returns to foreign investors if the local currency depreciates.

Conversely, a strengthening currency can amplify equity gains when converted into dollars.

For African capital markets seeking international investment, currency stability and the ability to repatriate proceeds are therefore important alongside corporate profitability.

Zimbabwe’s challenge is to ensure that improved share valuations are accompanied by deeper liquidity, transparent price discovery and greater confidence in the convertibility and availability of investment funds.

The role of corporate earnings and market liquidity

A sustainable stock market rally generally requires support from corporate earnings, dividend prospects, productivity improvements and investor confidence.

Zimbabwe’s listed companies operate across industries including banking, telecommunications, consumer goods, property, manufacturing and agriculture.

Their financial performance is influenced by domestic demand, import costs, financing conditions and the availability of foreign currency.

Where corporate earnings improve, higher share prices may reflect stronger expectations of future profitability.

However, Zimbabwe’s equity market also faces liquidity constraints.

Relatively modest trading volumes can produce significant movements in share prices, particularly where a limited number of investors compete for shares in companies with restricted free floats.

This can make headline index returns more volatile than those of larger, deeper exchanges.

Consequently, the quality of the rally is as important as its size.

Broad-based gains supported by rising turnover and improved company earnings would provide stronger evidence of renewed investor confidence than price appreciation concentrated in a small number of securities.

The distinction also matters for institutional investors, whose ability to enter and exit positions depends on sufficient market depth.

Zimbabwe’s economic recovery faces a capital-market test

The reported equity gains come as Zimbabwe continues efforts to improve its international financial standing through debt-resolution discussions and economic reforms.

Progress in addressing external arrears and restoring relations with international creditors could eventually influence the country’s sovereign-risk premium.

A lower perceived sovereign risk would potentially improve access to international credit lines for domestic financial institutions and businesses.

That, in turn, could help reduce the cost of capital and support investment in productive industries.

However, improved international financing conditions would depend on the credibility of reforms, the resolution of outstanding obligations and the willingness of lenders to extend new facilities.

For Zimbabwe, the challenge is to connect financial-market performance with investment in factories, agricultural productivity, infrastructure and formal employment.

A rising stock market is economically more significant when listed companies can use stronger valuations to raise capital and expand productive capacity.

Without that connection, equity gains may remain largely confined to existing shareholders.

Tanzania, Uganda and Ghana underline wider African momentum

Zimbabwe’s performance is part of a broader pattern of positive equity returns across several African markets.

Tanzania’s reported 66% gain places it close behind Zimbabwe, while Uganda and Ghana recorded advances exceeding 60%.

These figures suggest that investor interest has extended to markets outside Africa’s largest economies.

The BRVM’s reported 55% rise also points to significant gains across the regional exchange serving members of the West African Economic and Monetary Union.

Such performances may reflect a combination of domestic economic developments, company-specific results and changing investor expectations.

However, each market operates under different monetary conditions, listing structures and trading rules.

Comparisons should therefore account for the index selected, dividends, currency changes and the date at which returns were calculated.

A market ranking based solely on local-currency price appreciation provides a useful snapshot, but not a complete measure of comparative investment performance.

South Africa’s contrasting performance

The supplied figures also indicate that South Africa’s Johannesburg Stock Exchange All Share Index was approximately 4% lower for the year at the comparison date.

If confirmed on a consistent measurement basis, the divergence would underline how differently African equity markets can perform despite their geographical proximity.

South Africa has a substantially larger and more internationally integrated equity market than Zimbabwe.

Its listed companies are exposed to global commodity prices, international interest rates, exchange-rate movements and developments in major overseas economies.

Zimbabwe’s market, by contrast, is smaller and more heavily influenced by domestic liquidity conditions and local monetary developments.

The two markets therefore cannot be assessed using headline percentage changes alone.

For investors, the contrast highlights the need to distinguish market size, sector composition, currency exposure and underlying economic fundamentals.

Investors must look beyond the headline numbers

Zimbabwe’s reported position at the top of the African equity performance table is an encouraging development for the country’s capital-market narrative.

It suggests that domestic share valuations have strengthened significantly during 2026.

However, the sustainability of those gains will depend on factors extending beyond investor sentiment.

Monetary stability, credible corporate reporting, improved trading liquidity and continued progress in resolving Zimbabwe’s external financing constraints will remain important.

The government also faces the challenge of translating macroeconomic stability into wider improvements in household incomes, formal employment and private-sector investment.

For investors, the most useful question is not simply whether Zimbabwe has delivered the continent’s largest percentage gain.

It is whether that performance reflects a durable improvement in the country’s capacity to generate corporate earnings, mobilise savings and finance productive economic activity.

If the rally is supported by stronger company fundamentals and sustained monetary credibility, it could mark an important stage in the development of Zimbabwe’s capital markets.

If it is driven predominantly by nominal price adjustments or limited liquidity, the headline performance may overstate the underlying improvement.

Zimbabwe’s 71% gain has nevertheless placed its stock market at the centre of an important African investment discussion.

The next test will be whether that market momentum can translate into greater financial depth, lower investment risk and lasting economic opportunities.

The post Zimbabwe Leads African Stock Markets in 2026 With 71% Gain appeared first on The Zimbabwe Mail.

Mbeki Rejects Apartheid Cover-Up Allegations as South Africa Confronts Decades of Denied Justice

JOHANNESBURG — Former South African President Thabo Mbeki has categorically denied allegations that his administration obstructed the investigation and prosecution of apartheid-era crimes, defending his government’s record before a judicial inquiry examining why hundreds of cases involving killings, disappearances and other human rights violations were never brought before the courts. Appearing before the inquiry in […]

The post Mbeki Rejects Apartheid Cover-Up Allegations as South Africa Confronts Decades of Denied Justice appeared first on The Zimbabwe Mail.

JOHANNESBURG — Former South African President Thabo Mbeki has categorically denied allegations that his administration obstructed the investigation and prosecution of apartheid-era crimes, defending his government’s record before a judicial inquiry examining why hundreds of cases involving killings, disappearances and other human rights violations were never brought before the courts.

Appearing before the inquiry in Johannesburg on Monday, Mbeki rejected claims that he had instructed prosecutors to abandon cases or entered into secret arrangements protecting former apartheid security officials from criminal accountability.

His testimony, reported by Associated Press correspondent Michelle Gumede, comes amid renewed demands from victims’ families for answers about the failure of successive democratic administrations to prosecute crimes committed under white minority rule.

“It’s a complete fabrication. There was no such thing,” Mbeki told the inquiry, according to the Associated Press.

The former president, who succeeded Nelson Mandela in 1999 and governed South Africa until 2008, maintained that responsibility for explaining the failure to prosecute cases referred by the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) rested with the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA).

His appearance represents a significant moment in South Africa’s continuing struggle to reconcile the political compromises that accompanied democracy with the constitutional obligation to deliver justice for victims of apartheid.

Mbeki denies secret agreements with apartheid generals

At the centre of the inquiry are allegations that political considerations influenced decisions not to prosecute former security officials implicated in serious human rights violations.

Among the accusations against Mbeki are claims that his administration held confidential discussions with former military commanders to negotiate arrangements that would protect them from prosecution.

The former president acknowledged meeting former military and police officers but rejected suggestions that the discussions produced agreements granting them immunity.

He maintained that the purpose of those engagements was to encourage participation in the Truth and Reconciliation Commission’s processes.

The distinction is legally significant.

While the commission provided a mechanism through which perpetrators could seek amnesty in exchange for full disclosure, it did not establish a general exemption from criminal prosecution.

Individuals who failed to apply for amnesty or whose applications were rejected remained liable to prosecution.

Mbeki’s position is that his administration did not interfere with that legal framework or instruct prosecutors to disregard cases requiring further investigation.

The controversial 2003 parliamentary address

The inquiry has also revisited Mbeki’s April 2003 parliamentary response to the Truth and Reconciliation Commission’s final report.

In that address, the former president referred to the possibility of prosecutors working with intelligence agencies to reach lawful arrangements with individuals prepared to provide information about historical crimes.

Critics have argued that the statement created political space for negotiations that could undermine criminal accountability.

Mbeki rejected that interpretation during his testimony.

He explained that his remarks concerned individuals who had not participated in the commission’s amnesty process, rather than suspects whose cases had already been referred for prosecution.

According to his account, the parliamentary statement did not authorise blanket amnesty or remove the NPA’s constitutional authority to determine whether criminal charges should be brought.

The former president also distinguished presidential pardons from prosecutorial decisions.

He argued that pardons applied to individuals who had already been convicted and therefore could not, by themselves, prevent the investigation or prosecution of unresolved crimes.

The inquiry must now consider whether the documentary record and testimony from other witnesses support his explanation.

Families demand answers after decades of waiting

For the families of apartheid victims, the proceedings represent another opportunity to establish why justice remained elusive long after South Africa’s democratic transition.

Ahead of Mbeki’s appearance, the Foundation for Human Rights and 25 families of victims and survivors called for a comprehensive explanation of the delays.

They also sought an apology for the prolonged failure to resolve cases involving their relatives.

The foundation’s executive director, Zaid Kimmie, expressed frustration over the absence of accountability.

The Associated Press quoted him as saying that families wanted a candid explanation after years of waiting.

Their demands highlight the human consequences of institutional delays.

For many families, the end of apartheid did not bring closure concerning the circumstances in which relatives were killed or disappeared.

Instead, unanswered questions persisted as witnesses aged, evidence deteriorated and some suspected perpetrators died before facing trial.

The passage of time has made successful prosecutions increasingly difficult, creating concerns that some families may never obtain judicial findings concerning the deaths of their relatives.

The unfinished business of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission

South Africa established the Truth and Reconciliation Commission in 1996 under the chairmanship of Archbishop Desmond Tutu.

The commission became one of the most internationally recognised institutions associated with the country’s transition from apartheid to democracy.

Its central purpose was to establish the truth about politically motivated human rights violations while providing a conditional amnesty process for perpetrators prepared to disclose their actions fully.

The arrangement reflected the difficult political compromises accompanying South Africa’s negotiated transition.

However, the commission was never intended to replace the criminal justice system entirely.

Those who did not qualify for amnesty remained subject to prosecution.

According to figures cited by the Associated Press, the commission received approximately 7,000 amnesty applications.

An interim Justice Department tally recorded roughly 850 approvals and about 5,400 refusals by November 2000, with other applications partially approved, withdrawn or still under consideration.

A subsequent review commissioned by the NPA identified approximately 300 cases referred for further investigation and possible prosecution.

Yet only a small number ultimately resulted in successful prosecutions.

The discrepancy between the number of referrals and the number of completed criminal cases lies at the heart of the present inquiry.

Did reconciliation come at the expense of justice?

The proceedings have reopened one of the most difficult questions in South Africa’s democratic history: whether political stability and national reconciliation were prioritised at the expense of accountability.

The African National Congress played a central role in the struggle against apartheid and subsequently led the country’s transition to democratic government in 1994.

Under Mandela, the new administration sought to avoid renewed political conflict while establishing democratic institutions and dismantling the legal structures of racial segregation.

The Truth and Reconciliation Commission emerged from that historical context.

However, critics argue that reconciliation could not legitimately provide permanent protection from prosecution for individuals implicated in serious crimes.

The distinction between forgiveness and legal accountability has become increasingly important as families seek explanations for decades of prosecutorial inactivity.

Mbeki’s testimony suggests that he rejects the premise that his administration deliberately sacrificed justice to protect former apartheid officials.

Nevertheless, the inquiry must establish whether political decisions, administrative failures or improper interference contributed to the absence of prosecutions.

Ramaphosa’s inquiry confronts successive administrations

President Cyril Ramaphosa ordered the judicial inquiry in April 2026 after survivors and victims’ families pursued legal action against successive governments over their failure to investigate unresolved apartheid-era crimes.

The inquiry is chaired by retired Constitutional Court Justice Sisi Khampepe.

Its work extends beyond Mbeki’s presidency and examines the institutional decisions that may have prevented investigations and prosecutions from proceeding.

Mbeki and his successor, Jacob Zuma, previously challenged Khampepe’s appointment, arguing that her earlier involvement with the Truth and Reconciliation Commission and the NPA compromised her impartiality.

The Constitutional Court dismissed their challenge, allowing the inquiry to proceed under her leadership.

The legal dispute demonstrated the sensitivity of the investigation, which potentially implicates decisions taken at the highest levels of South Africa’s democratic governments.

The inquiry is expected to consider testimony from former senior officials alongside documentary evidence relating to the handling of apartheid-era cases.

Historic deaths return to the courts

The renewed investigation coincides with efforts to revisit several of South Africa’s most historically significant unresolved deaths.

Authorities have reopened inquests involving prominent anti-apartheid figures, including former African National Congress president and Nobel Peace Prize laureate Albert Luthuli.

Luthuli died in 1967 under circumstances that have continued to attract scrutiny.

The 1981 killing of human rights lawyer Griffiths Mxenge has also returned to the judicial agenda.

Another prominent case concerns Steve Biko, the Black Consciousness leader who died in police custody in 1977.

Biko’s death became an international symbol of the brutality of apartheid’s security apparatus.

The reopening of these matters reflects the continuing importance of establishing an authoritative historical and legal record.

However, renewed inquests do not automatically guarantee criminal convictions.

Investigators must still confront the difficulties created by missing evidence, deceased witnesses and the passage of several decades.

The National Prosecuting Authority faces difficult questions

Mbeki’s defence places particular emphasis on the independence and responsibilities of the NPA.

South Africa’s constitutional framework requires prosecutorial decisions to be made according to law rather than political instruction.

If cases were abandoned or delayed because of improper interference, the inquiry will need to establish who exercised that influence and through which institutional mechanisms.

Equally, if the failures resulted from administrative weaknesses, inadequate resources or poor investigative decisions, those findings would raise separate questions about institutional accountability.

Mbeki’s denial does not settle those issues.

His testimony represents one part of a wider evidential process involving former government officials, prosecutors and individuals connected to the historical cases.

The inquiry’s eventual findings will be important in determining whether the failures were systemic, politically motivated or attributable to a combination of factors.

Mbeki’s testimony to continue

The former president is scheduled to continue giving evidence on Tuesday, with three former Cabinet ministers expected to appear later in the week.

Zuma’s appearance, initially scheduled for Thursday, has been postponed, with a new date yet to be announced.

The proceedings are likely to remain politically sensitive because they examine decisions taken by administrations that helped shape post-apartheid South Africa.

For Mbeki, the inquiry presents an opportunity to defend his presidential record against allegations of interference in the criminal justice system.

For the families of victims, however, the stakes extend far beyond the reputations of former political leaders.

They are seeking an explanation of why democratic institutions failed to resolve crimes inherited from apartheid and whether those failures can still be remedied.

More than three decades after South Africa’s first democratic elections, the country continues to confront the unfinished legal consequences of its past.

The inquiry’s significance will ultimately depend not only on whether it establishes responsibility for historical failures, but also on whether its findings produce meaningful accountability for families who have waited decades for justice.

The post Mbeki Rejects Apartheid Cover-Up Allegations as South Africa Confronts Decades of Denied Justice appeared first on The Zimbabwe Mail.

Charamba Under Fire Over Mnangagwa and Chiwenga Speeches

HARARE — Presidential spokesman George Charamba has found himself at the centre of a growing political controversy after President Emmerson Mnangagwa and Vice-President Constantino Chiwenga delivered sharply contrasting messages at ZANU-PF’s 23rd National People’s Conference in Chinhoyi, raising questions about political coordination, presidential communication and the deepening divisions within the ruling party. The controversy erupted […]

The post Charamba Under Fire Over Mnangagwa and Chiwenga Speeches appeared first on The Zimbabwe Mail.

HARARE — Presidential spokesman George Charamba has found himself at the centre of a growing political controversy after President Emmerson Mnangagwa and Vice-President Constantino Chiwenga delivered sharply contrasting messages at ZANU-PF’s 23rd National People’s Conference in Chinhoyi, raising questions about political coordination, presidential communication and the deepening divisions within the ruling party.

The controversy erupted after both leaders invoked the same Shona expression, mazvake mazvake, broadly referring to individualism or the pursuit of personal interests, during their addresses to delegates.

Although the two leaders appeared to be advocating collective responsibility, the political context and contrasting emphasis of their speeches have fuelled speculation that each was directing a veiled warning at the other.

Charamba, who serves as Mnangagwa’s official spokesman and has maintained longstanding political relationships across the ruling party’s leadership, has consequently become the subject of accusations that the administration’s communications machinery failed to reconcile the competing messages.

Former ZANU-PF Mashonaland West provincial chairman and former Norton legislator Temba Mliswa has entered the dispute, questioning Charamba’s role and calling for his dismissal if he was responsible for preparing or influencing the apparently contradictory speeches.

The allegations have not established that Charamba authored either address, let alone both. Nevertheless, they have brought renewed attention to the difficulties facing a presidential communications office operating within an increasingly contested political environment.

One expression, two competing political messages

The controversy centres on the expression mazvake mazvake, which both Mnangagwa and Chiwenga employed during the conference.

Chiwenga, speaking before introducing the President, warned against the pursuit of individual interests within the ruling party.

“Mazvake mazvake haana kwaanotisvitsa,” he declared, meaning that the pursuit of personal agendas would not take the party anywhere.

His remarks formed part of a broader appeal for political discipline, institutional accountability and an honest examination of ZANU-PF’s leadership.

The Vice-President challenged the party to consider whether the Second Republic was repeating the political mistakes that contributed to the collapse of Robert Mugabe’s presidency in November 2017.

He also questioned the growing emphasis on individual political ambitions at the expense of collective decision-making.

Mnangagwa subsequently used the same expression while addressing delegates.

“MuZANU-PF hakuna mazvake mazvake,” the President declared, emphasising that there was no room for individual agendas within the ruling party.

While the language was similar, the juxtaposition of the speeches invited competing interpretations.

Chiwenga’s intervention appeared to challenge the political culture surrounding leadership succession and the concentration of authority.

Mnangagwa’s remarks, meanwhile, could be interpreted as a reaffirmation of presidential authority and a warning against individual political manoeuvring.

Neither statement, taken alone, establishes that one leader was directly attacking the other.

However, against the backdrop of the succession debate, the repeated expression became a focal point for speculation about the relationship between the two men.

Mliswa turns his attention to Charamba

Mliswa, a former ZANU-PF provincial chairman who later established himself as an outspoken independent parliamentarian, criticised Chiwenga’s address and questioned the effectiveness of the government’s communications arrangements.

He characterised the Vice-President’s speech as “corrosive and discordant” when compared with Mnangagwa’s presentation.

His criticism extended beyond the substance of the addresses to the officials responsible for coordinating presidential communication.

Mliswa argued that if Charamba had played a role in producing contradictory messages for the country’s senior leadership, such conduct would raise serious questions about his suitability for office.

He described the situation as an “internal messaging disaster” and warned that a communications official responsible for such inconsistencies could represent an “existential danger to the coherence of the state”.

The remarks amounted to a direct challenge to Charamba’s professional judgement and political loyalty.

However, the argument rests on an assumption that the presidential spokesman exercised editorial control over both speeches.

No evidence supplied with the allegations establishes the extent of Charamba’s involvement in preparing either address.

The distinction matters because the President and Vice-President are separate political actors who may independently develop their own messages.

A difference in emphasis between their speeches does not necessarily demonstrate a failure by the communications office.

A veteran insider facing an unusually delicate challenge

Few officials have occupied Zimbabwe’s political communications establishment for as long as George Charamba.

His career spans the administrations of Canaan Banana, Robert Mugabe and Emmerson Mnangagwa, making him one of the most experienced figures in the country’s presidential bureaucracy.

Charamba entered the public service in 1984 as a press officer in the Ministry of Information, Posts and Telecommunications.

He subsequently served in the office of Zimbabwe’s first President, Canaan Banana, before joining Mugabe’s presidential information establishment following the constitutional changes of 1987.

In 1988, he became an Assistant Secretary in the President’s Information Unit, working under senior officials responsible for the administration’s public communications.

He later rose to become Mugabe’s official press secretary and subsequently Permanent Secretary for Information and Broadcasting Services.

Following the political transition of November 2017, Charamba retained an influential position within the new administration.

He currently serves as Deputy Chief Secretary for Presidential Communications in the Office of the President and Cabinet, alongside his responsibilities as presidential spokesman.

His longevity reflects an ability to navigate successive political administrations, changing leadership structures and the increasingly complex relationship between the State and the media.

Yet that experience also places him under particular scrutiny whenever contradictions emerge in official communication.

Serving the presidency amid political rivalry

The central question surrounding Charamba is whether a senior civil servant can maintain the confidence of competing political figures without becoming entangled in their differences.

As presidential spokesman, his formal responsibility is to communicate the position of the President and the administration.

His institutional role requires accuracy, discipline and consistency in presenting government policy.

However, the political realities of Zimbabwe’s executive structure are more complicated.

Chiwenga is not merely another Cabinet figure. He is Vice-President, a senior ZANU-PF official and one of the principal figures associated with the political transition that brought Mnangagwa to power.

The two leaders share responsibility for government, but their respective political constituencies and approaches to leadership succession have become subjects of increasing public debate.

In such circumstances, the communications office must distinguish between legitimate differences in political emphasis and messages that create confusion about government policy.

It is also important to recognise that party conference speeches are political communications rather than necessarily formal statements of government policy.

The same phrase can carry different political meanings depending on the speaker, audience and surrounding argument.

Consequently, the appearance of mazvake mazvake in both speeches is insufficient evidence that Charamba drafted them or deliberately engineered a confrontation.

The long-running Charamba–Mliswa feud

The latest controversy has also revived the longstanding antagonism between Charamba and Mliswa.

The two men have previously exchanged public criticism over political loyalty, government communication and the conduct of influential figures within ZANU-PF.

Mliswa has repeatedly challenged Charamba’s position within the administration, while the presidential spokesman has responded dismissively to his political interventions.

Their disagreements reflect contrasting approaches to political influence.

Charamba’s authority derives largely from decades of service within the executive bureaucracy and his proximity to successive presidents.

Mliswa, by contrast, has built much of his public profile through political confrontation, independent campaigning and a willingness to criticise powerful figures within his former party.

After serving as ZANU-PF’s Mashonaland West provincial chairman, Mliswa went on to represent Norton in Parliament as an independent legislator.

His political career has demonstrated an ability to remain prominent outside the conventional structures of party leadership.

That independence has allowed him to challenge figures within both government and opposition, although his interventions have also attracted criticism for their confrontational character.

His latest attack on Charamba therefore needs to be understood within the context of a much longer personal and political disagreement.

Charamba’s complicated relationship with the media

Beyond his role in presidential communication, Charamba has developed a reputation as one of Zimbabwe’s most combative government communicators.

During earlier periods of his career, he maintained professional relationships with journalists across the political spectrum, including members of the independent media.

His approach was not always confrontational, and he was known to facilitate interactions between journalists and government institutions.

However, his public communication style increasingly became associated with sharp political commentary and personal exchanges with critics.

He has faced criticism over his use of newspaper commentary and social media to challenge political opponents, journalists and media organisations.

Critics have also accused the presidential communications establishment of adopting an uneven approach to media access.

Such allegations should be distinguished from independently established misconduct, but they illustrate the controversy that has accompanied Charamba’s public career.

His supporters may regard his combative style as an effective defence of government policy against hostile criticism.

His detractors see it as evidence of excessive political partisanship in an office that should maintain professional standards of public communication.

The present dispute places those competing assessments under renewed scrutiny.

Chinhoyi exposes the challenge of managing succession

The communications controversy cannot be separated from the wider political debate surrounding Mnangagwa’s future.

ZANU-PF’s conference took place amid competing proposals concerning leadership continuity, constitutional arrangements and the party’s succession timetable.

Supporters of Mnangagwa have argued that continued leadership would provide stability and allow the government to complete its economic development programme.

Others have questioned the constitutional and institutional implications of extending political authority beyond established limits.

Chiwenga’s conference intervention placed particular emphasis on accountability and the principles underpinning the Second Republic.

His warning against individual ambition was therefore politically significant, even without an explicit reference to Mnangagwa.

The President’s subsequent insistence that ZANU-PF has no place for personal agendas added another dimension to the debate.

The fact that both leaders invoked collective responsibility while appearing to address different political concerns illustrates the difficulty of maintaining a unified party message.

For Charamba, the challenge is especially sensitive because communication cannot resolve substantive disagreements that may exist within the political leadership.

A spokesman can clarify official positions, but cannot necessarily eliminate competing ambitions or differences in political judgement.

A communications dispute with wider implications

The episode raises questions extending beyond Charamba’s individual performance.

Effective government communication depends on clearly defined institutional responsibilities, credible information and public confidence that official statements accurately reflect policy.

Where senior leaders deliver apparently conflicting political messages, uncertainty can arise over the administration’s priorities.

That uncertainty becomes more significant when the disagreements concern leadership succession, constitutional arrangements or the future direction of the ruling party.

However, calls for the dismissal of a public official require a stronger evidential basis than speculation over similarities in political language.

Establishing responsibility would require clarity about who drafted the speeches, who approved them and whether any formal communication procedures were breached.

Without that evidence, allegations that Charamba attempted to serve two political masters remain unproven.

What is beyond dispute in the supplied account is that the contrasting interpretations of Mnangagwa’s and Chiwenga’s remarks have become part of the wider political contest within ZANU-PF.

The problem may be political rather than rhetorical

Ultimately, the controversy surrounding mazvake mazvake reveals the limitations of political messaging when questions of leadership and institutional authority remain unresolved.

Mnangagwa and Chiwenga both appealed to the principle that ZANU-PF should place collective interests above individual ambition.

Yet the political reaction to their speeches suggests that the meaning of that principle is itself contested.

For one constituency, it may represent a demand for loyalty to the incumbent President and the continuation of his development programme.

For another, it may signify the need to uphold institutional procedures and prevent the concentration of political power around individual leaders.

Charamba’s predicament is therefore not simply about the repeated use of a Shona expression.

It is about the difficulty of communicating unity when influential figures and their supporters may hold different expectations about the party’s future.

Whether the presidential spokesman played any role in shaping the two addresses remains to be established.

But the political storm surrounding him illustrates a larger challenge confronting ZANU-PF: the management of competing leadership expectations within an organisation publicly committed to collective responsibility.

For a communications veteran who has served three presidential administrations, the Chinhoyi controversy may prove another test of his political judgement.

The more important question, however, is whether the ruling party’s leadership can reconcile its differences through established institutions rather than allowing them to develop into an increasingly public contest of political messaging.

The post Charamba Under Fire Over Mnangagwa and Chiwenga Speeches appeared first on The Zimbabwe Mail.

‘ZANU-PF Delegates Are Dogs’: Mavetera Sparks Outrage Over Alleged Insult to Chiwenga Supporters

HARARE — Zimbabwe’s Information Communication Technology Minister Tatenda Mavetera has become embroiled in a political controversy following allegations that she likened ZANU-PF delegates to dogs after they enthusiastically welcomed Vice President Constantino Chiwenga at the ruling party’s 23rd National People’s Conference in Chinhoyi. The reported remarks, highlighted in the October 17 edition of Takabatana Investigative […]

The post ‘ZANU-PF Delegates Are Dogs’: Mavetera Sparks Outrage Over Alleged Insult to Chiwenga Supporters appeared first on The Zimbabwe Mail.

HARARE — Zimbabwe’s Information Communication Technology Minister Tatenda Mavetera has become embroiled in a political controversy following allegations that she likened ZANU-PF delegates to dogs after they enthusiastically welcomed Vice President Constantino Chiwenga at the ruling party’s 23rd National People’s Conference in Chinhoyi.

The reported remarks, highlighted in the October 17 edition of Takabatana Investigative Magazine, have raised questions about political tolerance within ZANU-PF and the increasingly strained relationship between supporters of President Emmerson Mnangagwa and those sympathetic to his deputy.

According to the publication, Mavetera rebuked delegates who stood and applauded Chiwenga as he approached the conference podium, using the Shona expression “Imbwa inoroverwa painenge yabira”.

The expression, broadly understood to mean that a dog is beaten where it has stolen, was reportedly directed at delegates whose enthusiastic reception of the Vice President appeared to displease the minister.

The Zimbabwe Mail’s examination of the published account indicates that the controversy goes beyond the language allegedly used. It raises a wider question about whether ordinary party members are free to express their political preferences without intimidation or humiliation.

The allegation has not been independently verified by The Zimbabwe Mail, and the supplied publication does not include Mavetera’s response.

Delegates’ applause becomes a political flashpoint

The controversy reportedly unfolded against the backdrop of Chiwenga’s address to the conference, during which he challenged ZANU-PF to undertake what he described as a brutal and honest assessment of its leadership and political direction.

The Vice President questioned whether the governing party was repeating the mistakes that led to the removal of former President Robert Mugabe in November 2017.

His remarks placed accountability, institutional integrity and the participation of ordinary party members at the centre of the conference’s political debate.

Chiwenga’s message was particularly significant given the continuing controversy surrounding proposals to extend Mnangagwa’s leadership beyond the constitutional presidential term ending in 2028.

The Vice President has emphasised that political authority should derive from party structures and members rather than the personal ambitions of individual leaders.

His argument challenged the increasingly personalised nature of Zimbabwe’s succession debate.

According to Takabatana, delegates responded enthusiastically to Chiwenga’s presence, standing to welcome him as he approached the podium.

It was this reception that reportedly prompted Mavetera’s intervention.

The publication alleged that the minister subsequently told delegates that their enthusiasm should be reserved for Mnangagwa, suggesting that applause for the Vice President was politically inappropriate.

If accurately reported, the incident would highlight the difficulty facing ZANU-PF as it attempts to maintain an appearance of internal unity while managing competing political loyalties.

Chiwenga’s popularity and the question of political loyalty

Chiwenga occupies one of the most senior positions in ZANU-PF and the Zimbabwean government.

As Vice President and Second Secretary of the ruling party, he is not an outsider seeking recognition from its membership.

He is a central figure in the political administration established following Mugabe’s departure.

His public reception at a national party conference would ordinarily be regarded as a legitimate expression of support for a senior leader.

The reported controversy therefore raises a fundamental question: why should delegates face criticism for applauding a constitutional office-holder and senior party official?

Within a political organisation that publicly champions collective leadership and grassroots participation, expressions of support for different leaders should not automatically be interpreted as acts of disloyalty.

Yet the incident described by Takabatana suggests that the symbolism of applause has become politically sensitive.

The enthusiastic reception of one leader can be interpreted by supporters of another as an indication of shifting political allegiances.

Such interpretations risk turning routine party gatherings into contests over personal loyalty rather than opportunities to debate policy and national development.

The significance of Mavetera’s alleged remarks

The language attributed to Mavetera has attracted particular attention because of its apparent contempt for ordinary delegates.

ZANU-PF’s conference participants include provincial representatives, long-serving party organisers, community leaders and grassroots activists who contribute to the organisation’s political mobilisation.

Many travel considerable distances to attend national gatherings, often after years of involvement in local party structures.

Their participation forms part of the institutional foundation upon which the ruling party has maintained its political influence since independence.

The use of a derogatory comparison against such members, if confirmed, would raise questions about the standards of conduct expected from senior public officials.

It would also expose a contradiction between the party’s stated commitment to grassroots leadership and the treatment allegedly directed towards delegates exercising their right to applaud a senior official.

Mavetera, as a Cabinet minister, holds responsibilities extending beyond internal party politics.

Her public conduct is therefore subject to expectations of professionalism, restraint and respect for citizens, including those whose political preferences may differ from her own.

The central issue is not whether delegates support Mnangagwa or Chiwenga, but whether political differences justify language that could reasonably be perceived as degrading.

Chiwenga’s call for self-examination acquires new significance

The controversy comes at a particularly sensitive moment because Chiwenga’s conference message was itself centred on accountability.

He urged ZANU-PF to reflect on its political conduct and examine whether the Second Republic had remained faithful to the principles that accompanied its establishment.

The Vice President’s intervention suggested that political renewal requires more than economic development targets and conference resolutions.

It also demands institutional discipline, respect for members and a willingness to confront uncomfortable questions.

The allegations surrounding Mavetera’s remarks, if substantiated, would illustrate precisely the kind of internal political culture that such self-examination might need to address.

A party that encourages members to participate in its structures must also provide space for disagreement and differing assessments of its leadership.

Otherwise, grassroots participation risks becoming a ceremonial exercise in which members are expected to endorse decisions rather than contribute meaningfully to them.

The Mnangagwa succession debate intensifies

The Chinhoyi conference took place amid renewed debate over ZANU-PF’s leadership arrangements and proposals associated with Mnangagwa’s continued political authority.

Supporters of the President have promoted continuity as necessary to consolidate economic reforms and achieve the government’s Vision 2030 development objectives.

Critics, however, have questioned whether changes to leadership arrangements could weaken constitutional safeguards and institutional accountability.

Chiwenga’s remarks have added weight to that debate by placing the principles of collective leadership and constitutional procedure at the forefront of the discussion.

His position does not necessarily amount to a formal challenge to Mnangagwa, but it has highlighted differences in emphasis within the ruling party.

The reported reaction to delegates applauding him suggests that those differences may be increasingly difficult to contain.

For ZANU-PF, the danger lies in allowing personal loyalties to overshadow the institutional rules that are supposed to govern leadership transitions.

Respect for grassroots members becomes the central issue

Beyond the immediate controversy, the allegations have implications for the relationship between political leaders and the members who sustain their organisations.

ZANU-PF frequently invokes its liberation history, grassroots mobilisation and popular participation as sources of political legitimacy.

Those traditions place ordinary members at the centre of the party’s identity.

However, meaningful participation requires more than attendance at conferences and public demonstrations of unity.

It requires members to retain the freedom to express support, question decisions and participate in debates without fear of humiliation.

The controversy surrounding Mavetera’s reported remarks therefore raises a broader institutional question about the boundaries of political loyalty.

A delegate’s decision to applaud Chiwenga does not, in itself, establish opposition to Mnangagwa.

Equally, support for the President should not require hostility towards his deputy.

Both leaders occupy senior positions within the same political organisation and government.

A political culture that treats admiration for one as betrayal of the other risks deepening divisions rather than resolving them.

Calls for clarification

The allegations published by Takabatana Investigative Magazine warrant clarification from Mavetera and the relevant ZANU-PF authorities.

The precise wording, context and intended audience of the reported remarks are important to establishing what occurred.

Without an authenticated recording or an on-the-record explanation, the allegation should not be treated as an independently established account of the minister’s conduct.

Nevertheless, the political questions raised by the report remain significant.

As ZANU-PF navigates an increasingly sensitive debate over its future leadership, its ability to accommodate different voices will be an important test of institutional maturity.

Chiwenga’s demand for honest self-examination has placed that issue squarely before the ruling party.

The controversy surrounding Mavetera now presents a practical question about whether such introspection will extend to the treatment of ordinary members.

For a party that derives much of its political identity from the liberation struggle and grassroots organisation, the dignity of its membership should remain central to its internal culture.

The ultimate test of ZANU-PF’s commitment to collective leadership may not be found in the resolutions adopted at Chinhoyi, but in whether its members can express political preferences without being subjected to ridicule by those holding public office.

The post ‘ZANU-PF Delegates Are Dogs’: Mavetera Sparks Outrage Over Alleged Insult to Chiwenga Supporters appeared first on The Zimbabwe Mail.

Billiat and Musona Put Scottland on Brink of Historic CAF Champions League Breakthrough

HARARE — Zimbabwean football giants Scottland FC moved within touching distance of a historic place in the CAF Champions League group stages after Khama Billiat and Knowledge Musona delivered the decisive blows in a 2-0 victory over Angolan heavyweights Petro de Luanda at the National Sports Stadium on Saturday. The victory handed Norman Mapeza’s ambitious […]

The post Billiat and Musona Put Scottland on Brink of Historic CAF Champions League Breakthrough appeared first on The Zimbabwe Mail.

HARARE — Zimbabwean football giants Scottland FC moved within touching distance of a historic place in the CAF Champions League group stages after Khama Billiat and Knowledge Musona delivered the decisive blows in a 2-0 victory over Angolan heavyweights Petro de Luanda at the National Sports Stadium on Saturday.

The victory handed Norman Mapeza’s ambitious side a significant advantage ahead of the second leg in Luanda, although the Zimbabwean champions were forced to work considerably harder than expected against opponents reduced to ten men almost immediately after kick-off.

In a contest that tested Scottland’s patience, tactical discipline and attacking creativity, two of Zimbabwe’s most experienced international footballers ultimately made the difference.

Billiat broke the deadlock midway through the second half before turning provider for Musona, whose finish doubled the advantage and transformed a potentially frustrating afternoon into an important continental result.

For Scottland, the outcome represents another significant moment in the club’s pursuit of recognition beyond Zimbabwe’s domestic football landscape.

Petro de Luanda suffer extraordinary opening-minute setback

The match began with a dramatic incident that appeared to give Scottland an immediate advantage.

Petro de Luanda goalkeeper Hugo Marques received a straight red card inside the opening minute after rushing outside his penalty area and bringing down Panashe Mutimbanyoka.

South African referee Abongile Tom dismissed the experienced goalkeeper, leaving the Angolan visitors to reorganise before the match had properly settled into its rhythm.

For Scottland, the incident created the prospect of an early breakthrough against opponents who arrived in Harare with considerable experience of continental competition.

However, the dismissal did not produce the attacking dominance the home supporters might have anticipated.

Instead, Petro de Luanda retreated into a compact defensive formation, denying Scottland space through central areas and forcing Mapeza’s players to search for openings against a disciplined defensive structure.

The situation carried uncomfortable similarities to Scottland’s earlier preliminary-round encounter against Eswatini’s Nsingizini Hotspurs.

In that match, Scottland’s opponents were also reduced to ten men in the opening minutes, yet the Zimbabwean side failed to capitalise on their numerical superiority and were held to a goalless draw.

For much of Saturday’s first half, another frustrating result appeared possible.

Mapeza’s tactical adjustment changes the contest

Despite controlling significant periods of possession, Scottland struggled to translate their numerical advantage into clear goalscoring opportunities.

Petro de Luanda’s defensive organisation frustrated the home side, with the visitors protecting central areas and limiting opportunities for Billiat and Musona.

The first half ended goalless, leaving Scottland facing the possibility of travelling to Angola without a home advantage despite playing almost the entire match against ten men.

Billiat threatened shortly after the restart but dragged his effort wide as the hosts continued searching for a breakthrough.

Mapeza responded by seeking greater attacking width, recognising that Petro de Luanda’s concentration of defenders in central positions made direct approaches increasingly ineffective.

The introduction of Walter Musona added another attacking dimension, with Scottland placing greater emphasis on deliveries from wide positions.

The tactical adjustment eventually produced the opening goal.

In the 66th minute, Billiat reacted sharply to a delivery from the right and guided the ball into the net, breaking Petro de Luanda’s resistance and releasing the tension that had built throughout the stadium.

The goal gave Scottland the advantage their pressure had threatened to produce but had previously failed to deliver.

Billiat and Knowledge Musona combine for decisive second

Having opened the scoring, Billiat quickly demonstrated why his experience remains so valuable to Scottland’s continental ambitions.

The former Mamelodi Sundowns and Kaizer Chiefs forward turned creator, finding Knowledge Musona in a dangerous position in front of goal.

Substitute goalkeeper Maulucano initially met Musona’s effort, but the ball rebounded off the goalkeeper and crossed the line.

The second goal provided Scottland with a valuable cushion ahead of the return fixture and rewarded the home side for maintaining their attacking pressure.

For Zimbabwean football supporters, the contributions of Billiat and Musona carried particular significance.

Both players have enjoyed distinguished careers in southern African football and have represented the Warriors at international level.

Their combination highlighted the value of experience in high-pressure continental fixtures, where moments of individual quality can determine the outcome of closely contested matches.

Billiat’s goal and assist were especially influential, providing Scottland with the attacking productivity they had lacked during the opening hour.

Mapeza praises patience against ten-man opponents

Speaking after the match, Mapeza acknowledged that Petro de Luanda’s early dismissal had not made Scottland’s task straightforward.

“Playing against 10 men is never easy. Such games are difficult,” the coach said.

He explained that his players had struggled to penetrate a heavily congested defensive structure during the first half.

“In the first half, we kept pushing. They were very organised, with so many players at the back,” Mapeza said.

The Scottland coach said he instructed his players to abandon repeated attempts to attack through the centre and instead exploit the wider areas of the pitch.

That decision proved decisive, with the goals coming after the home side began delivering more effectively from the flanks.

Mapeza also acknowledged the contribution of Walter Musona, whose introduction helped provide the attacking variation Scottland required.

His assessment reflected a familiar challenge in football: numerical superiority does not automatically guarantee victory against opponents prepared to defend deeply and sacrifice attacking ambition.

Scottland ultimately needed tactical flexibility as well as individual quality to turn their advantage into goals.

Scottland’s continental ambition gathers momentum

The result places Scottland in a strong position to reach the CAF Champions League group stages, an achievement that would represent a major milestone for the club.

Qualification would expose the Zimbabwean side to some of Africa’s most established football institutions and provide an opportunity to test its resources, organisation and playing standards against elite continental opposition.

It would also carry wider significance for Zimbabwean club football, which has struggled to maintain a consistent presence in the latter stages of major African competitions.

Continental success offers clubs opportunities to increase their international visibility, attract commercial partnerships and improve their competitive experience.

For Scottland, whose ambitions have attracted considerable attention within Zimbabwean football, reaching the group stages would represent tangible progress towards establishing the club as a serious continental competitor.

However, Petro de Luanda remain formidable opponents.

The Angolan club possess extensive experience in African competition and will have the advantage of playing the decisive fixture at home.

Scottland cannot assume that Saturday’s result has settled the tie.

Luanda return leg presents final hurdle

Mapeza’s players will travel to Angola with a two-goal aggregate advantage, knowing that another disciplined performance could secure their place in the group stages.

A victory or draw in the return leg would be sufficient to progress, while a one-goal defeat would also preserve their aggregate lead.

A two-goal defeat would leave the teams level on aggregate, with the applicable competition regulations determining how the tie is resolved.

The second leg is likely to present a different tactical challenge.

Petro de Luanda will be expected to attack more aggressively on home soil, potentially creating opportunities for Scottland to exploit space on the counterattack.

That scenario could suit the pace, movement and experience of Billiat and Knowledge Musona, provided the Zimbabwean side maintain defensive discipline.

For Mapeza, the immediate priority will be ensuring that his players approach the return fixture with the same concentration required to overcome Petro de Luanda’s stubborn resistance in Harare.

The coach will also be aware that the opening-minute dismissal was an exceptional circumstance unlikely to be repeated.

Scottland must therefore prepare to face the Angolan champions at full strength.

A result that could reshape Scottland’s African ambitions

Saturday’s victory was not an exhibition of relentless attacking football, but it demonstrated an important quality required of teams seeking success in continental competition: the ability to find solutions when opponents frustrate their preferred approach.

For more than an hour, Petro de Luanda appeared capable of escaping Harare with a goalless draw despite their numerical disadvantage.

Mapeza’s tactical intervention, combined with Billiat’s attacking intelligence and Musona’s finishing, ultimately changed the outcome.

Scottland now stand one result away from a potentially historic achievement.

The decisive question is whether the Zimbabwean side can protect its advantage in Luanda and convert a promising first-leg performance into qualification for the CAF Champions League group stages.

For Billiat, Musona and their teammates, the opportunity to take Scottland into African football’s premier club group competition is now firmly within reach.

The post Billiat and Musona Put Scottland on Brink of Historic CAF Champions League Breakthrough appeared first on The Zimbabwe Mail.