Covid-19: Zimbabwean business steps-in
THE Confederation of Zimbabwe Industries (CZI) has embarked on a national drive to fight the […]
Trusted Zimbabwean News Worldwide
THE Confederation of Zimbabwe Industries (CZI) has embarked on a national drive to fight the […]
Source: Presidential pardon discriminatory – NewsDay Zimbabwe A PRESIDENTIAL pardon is a withdrawal of a sentence for a class of persons by the President under the prerogative of mercy. The decision by President Emmerson Mnangagwa to pardon and decongest prisons amid the COVID-19 pandemic is praiseworthy. The presidential amnesty was granted through Clemency Order No […]
The post Presidential pardon discriminatory appeared first on Zimbabwe Situation.
Source: Presidential pardon discriminatory – NewsDay Zimbabwe
A PRESIDENTIAL pardon is a withdrawal of a sentence for a class of persons by the President under the prerogative of mercy. The decision by President Emmerson Mnangagwa to pardon and decongest prisons amid the COVID-19 pandemic is praiseworthy. The presidential amnesty was granted through Clemency Order No 1 of 2020 published by the Government gazette on March 27, 2020. For the purpose of this piece, I will refer to it as the clemency order.
That we have an egalitarian Constitution in Zimbabwe is a fact. This editorial attempts to show how a blanket pardon for female prisoners is discriminatory. It thereafter briefly outlines the other classes of prisoners who benefited from the recent presidential pardon.
Specified offences
Generally, a presidential pardon does not benefit persons convicted for ‘specified offences’.
In terms of paragraph 12 of the clemency order, ‘specified offence’ means committing, conspiring, inciting or attempting to commit murder, treason, public violence, carjacking, robbery, stock theft, rape or any sexual offence.
Prisoners who have previously been released on amnesty, those with a record of escaping from lawful custody and those serving a sentence imposed by a court martial did not benefit from the clemency order. A court martial is a military court convened to try military personnel.
Remission of sentence for all female prisoners
The clemency order commanded the release of all convicted female prisoners who had served at least half of their sentences by March 27, 2020. Women convicted for committing specified offences were, however, excluded from the pardon. Whilst it is accepted that no decision is made in a vacuum, there appear to be no legal justification for favoring women over men.
Subsection one of section 56 of the Constitution states that all persons are equal before the law and have the right to equal protection and benefit of the law. Section 56(2) expressly mentions that women and men have the right to equal treatment. Section 56(3) adds that every person has the right not to be treated in an unfairly discriminatory manner on the basis of gender among other grounds.
The Constitution gives room for what is known as fair discrimination. Put differently, there exist fair and unfair discrimination. Fair discrimination is permissible whilst unfair discrimination is unconstitutional. The Constitution states that discrimination is unfair unless if established that it is fair, reasonable and justifiable. Favouring women over men is therefore constitutional if the favour is fair, reasonable and justifiable in a democratic society.
Some may argue that section 56(6) of the Constitution obligates the government to take measures to advance classes of people who have been disadvantaged by unfair discrimination. The women’s electoral quota system for instance is fair, reasonable and justifiable because women have been disadvantaged in so far as politics and leadership is concerned.
Have women been disadvantaged by unfair discrimination in so far as amnesty/pardon is concerned?
The Constitutional Court of South Africa dealt with an analogous subject in President of SA and another versus Hugo. The case involved a decision by then President Nelson Mandela to pardon all imprisoned mothers who had children under the age of 12 years.
Philip Hugo, an imprisoned single father who had an 11-year-old child took the matter to court alleging that he had been unfairly discriminated. The Supreme Court ruled in Hugo’s favour and the President appealed. The Constitutional Court overturned the Supreme Court’s judgment. Two of the eleven ConCourt judges, however, concluded that the discrimination was unfair and therefore unconstitutional.
The presidential pardon which was the subject of Hugo case is distinguishable from clemency order 1 of 2020.
Mandela’s pardon ordered the release of all mothers with children under 12 years. Mnangagwa’s pardon ordered the release of all women. Mandela’s justification was that children below 12 years require motherly nurturing and care. What is Mnangagwa’s justification?
Think of a hypothetical case of a woman (Mary) who hires John to accompany her to C’s house. Upon arrival John is fraudulently introduced as Mary’s husband. Mary borrows US$ 5 000 from C on the misrepresentation that she would return the money after his ‘husband’ sells “their’ car. Seeing John’s car, C is convinced to give Mary the US$5 000. Mary and John are later convicted for committing fraud and sentenced to serve 40 months imprisonment.
In terms of paragraph 2 of the clemency order, Mary would be released from prison. Such a benefit of the law would not be available for John. There seems to be no reasonable justification for favouring Mary over John, a blanket approach to pardon all convicted women sounds unconstitutional. Though made in good faith, I opine that the clemency order in particular its paragraph 2 was unfairly discriminatory.
Other classes
All prisoners who had been ‘bed-ridden for a prolonged period without recovery’ were released. The clemency order did not however specify what a prolonged period is. The recent presidential saw all persons below the age of 18 and those above 70 years who had served half of their sentences going home.
Those who were convicted for committed rape, murder or other specified offences remained behind bars.
The clemency order also granted full remission of sentences to all prisoners that were serving a term of imprisonment at the open prison regardless of offences committed. There was also full remission of the remaining period of imprisonment to all prisoners who were serving effective 36 months and below. Only those who had served half of their sentence by March 27, 2020 were eligible to go home.
Prisoners serving an effective period of imprisonment of more than 36 months who had served a third of their remaining sentence were granted an additional one-quarter remission of the remaining effective period of imprisonment.
Prisoners who were sentenced to life imprisonment and who had served a minimum of 25 years were freed. All prisoners who were sentenced to death sentence and who had been on death roll for at least ten years have been spared death and will now spend the rest of their lives in prison.
Conclusion
Whilst the decision to decongest prisons through amnesty in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic is commendable, full remission of sentences for all female prisoners is arguably discriminatory and unconstitutional. If females who had served half of their sentences were allowed to go home, why should their male counterparts remain behind bars?
Fidelicy Nyamukondiwa writes here in his personal capacity. He is contactable on 0785827154 nhanyams@yahoo.com
The post Presidential pardon discriminatory appeared first on Zimbabwe Situation.
Source: An informed assault on the COVID-19 infodemic – NewsDay Zimbabwe It does not take a journalistic sage or a medical pundit to appreciate that the current COVID-19 pandemic is by all accounts historic. By David T C Mukwekwezeke Sadly, great notability has the inevitable penchant of attracting a deluge of opinions, conspiracies and a […]
The post An informed assault on the COVID-19 infodemic appeared first on Zimbabwe Situation.
Source: An informed assault on the COVID-19 infodemic – NewsDay Zimbabwe
It does not take a journalistic sage or a medical pundit to appreciate that the current COVID-19 pandemic is by all accounts historic.
By David T C Mukwekwezeke
Sadly, great notability has the inevitable penchant of attracting a deluge of opinions, conspiracies and a whole gamut of fiction which all tend to dilute the facts on a given topic.
This is what is called an infodemic, shorthand for “information epidemic”.
The World Health Organisation (WHO) popularised this term in their 13th 2019-nCov Situation Report published on February 2, 2019 in which they defined an infodemic as, “an overabundance of information – some accurate and some not – that makes it hard for people to find trustworthy sources and reliable guidance when they need it”.
They went on to advise all governments to be wary of this scourge and work closely with WHO technical risk communication and social media teams, also collectively and colloquially branded “the infodemic team”.
Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, the WHO Director-General, reiterated this caution a few days later during a media briefing on February 8 when he said: “At WHO, we’re not just battling the virus; we’re also battling the trolls and conspiracy theorists that push misinformation and undermine the outbreak response.”
He went on to quote the famous Guardian headline published on the same day: “Misinformation on the coronavirus might be the most contagious thing about it.”
These sentiments have since been vindicated and if anything, this infodemic seems to be aggravating with each passing day.
Some of the dangerous myths that have been propagated include the efficacy of lemons and other concoctions in treating the symptoms of COVID-19, the claim that those younger than 50 years and black people are safe from the virus and the latest and by far the most dangerous conspiracy theory is that of 5G and vaccines.
I endeavour to robustly refute these four myths in turn.
The first class of myths revolves around the treatment of COVID-19.
Various herbal remedies have been widely circulated as being effective such as lemons, turmeric, garlic, ginger, eucalyptus leaves and guava tree leaves.
There has been no scientific evidence that any of these therapies work.
Numerous already-known drugs have also been touted as therapeutic.
The two most famous of these have been chloroquine (or hydroxychloroquine) and Lopinavir/Ritonavir.
Chloroquine is an antimalarial drug with amebicidal action meaning it treats malaria but can also be used to treat an infectious disease called amebiasis.
It has also been approved for use in treating autoimmune diseases such as Rheumatoid Arthritis and Systemic Lupus Erythematosus (commonly called Lupus or SLE).
The reason why it offered so much hope was that laboratory studies revealed that it prevented SARS-COV-2 from entering cells in vitro (in petri dishes).
However, clinical trials into its efficacy in treating COVID-19 either on its own or in combination with a common antibiotic called Azithromycin are still in their infancy so consequently the evidence is also still weak.
Lopinavir/ritonavir is a fixed antiretroviral drug combination belonging to the Protease Inhibitor class which is currently reserved for second-line and third-line HIV treatment in Zimbabwe.
It goes by the brand names Kaletra or Aluvia.
The most notable study in academic literature published by a team led by Bin Cao in the New England Journal of Medicine on March 18 concluded that “in hospitalised adult patients with severe COVID-19, no benefit was observed with Lopinavir/ritonavir treatment beyond standard care”.
Various scientific investigations are being done all over the world to find an effective treatment for this novel disease and the largest of these is the “Solidarity” clinical trial being spearheaded by WHO as they compare four treatment options against standard therapies.
In short, all this means that so far there is no proven treatment for COVID-19.
The next class of fallacies is that of the demographic presentation of COVID-19.
The first myth is that the virus only infects the older generations.
This simplistic assertion is misleading.
The fact is that the virus can infect all ages but it tends to cause more severe disease in the older portions of the population.
A prime example is Italy where over 90% of all deaths were among those above the age of 50 years.
However, a much more reliable study into the demographic profile of COVID-19 was published on April 8 by the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC).
They confirmed that hospitalisation rates for COVID-19 increased with age.
The highest was among people above the age of 65 years with the rates ranging from 12.2% to 17.2% of all confirmed COVID-19 cases requiring admission into a hospital.
Interestingly, the figures also revealed that more men were hospitalised compared to women.
The second myth within this class (demographic presentation) is that of racial profiling of the coronavirus.
The current trend in the US, where the virus is now hitting the black population the hardest, effectively puts to bed the initial misguided claim that this virus does not infect black people.
Perhaps the most sobering figures are those of the US state of Louisiana where a shocking 70% of COVID-19 deaths were among African Americans despite them constituting only 33% of the state’s population.
It is important to note that the actual demographic profile of COVID-19 is fluid and will continue to change as the pandemic evolves.
These figures should not in any way proffer false comfort and complacency if one belongs to any of the population groups with more favourable statistics.
Prevention remains key for any age, gender or race.
The last class of myths I wish to rebuff is that of 5G (shorthand for Fifth Generation wireless technology) and vaccines.
This is by far the most toxic and most elaborate conspiracy theory we have encountered during this pandemic.
Its most prominent proponent is the former footballer and sports broadcaster turned conspiracy theorist, David Icke, whose YouTube interview with London Real on April 6 was so inflammatory that it pushed the Google-owned video-sharing site to institute a policy of banning all videos linking COVID-19 to 5G technology.
The ecclesiastic fraternity has also joined the fray in promoting this theory.
The basic analogy of this dangerous conspiracy theory is that 5G towers are emitting radiation which damages human cells causing them to produce genetic material which is being “interpreted as the novel coronavirus” when one is tested.
The malicious theory goes on to claim that this is a front for introducing a vaccine with “nanotechnology microchips”, which will be made compulsory and used to control the world population. Some religious groups go a step further and assert that this vaccine is the “mark of the beast” mentioned in the Bible.
These erroneous claims have led to the immolation of 5G towers in Britain, Northern Ireland and Brazil in protest.
It is important to note that there is no scientific evidence that 5G technology is harmful to the human body.
This was corroborated by the International Commission on Non-ionising Radiation Protection (ICNIRP) in its latest report published last month following a seven-year study.
On the other hand, vaccines for COVID-19 are indeed being developed across the globe but the most promising ones do not incorporate nanotechnology but rather DNA and messenger RNA (mRNA).
On top of that, it is important to remember that vaccines are only used on humans after a thorough, transparent and verifiable process so the chances of anyone getting a vaccine whose ingredients are unknown are almost negligible.
In conclusion, there is only one way to refute any conspiracy theory and that is through hard evidence.
All these variations of the current infodemic will only serve to breed anxiety, fear and complacency in adhering to proven measures that will help defeat this pandemic.
What is undebatable is that the world will never be the same after this scourge.
It is indeed the dawn of a new era.
Whether that era is bright or dark will only be answered by the most consistent of scientific theories, time itself.
For now, let us wash our hands, cover our coughs, stay at home and take each day as it comes.
Dr David T C Mukwekwezeke is a medical doctor and human rights defender. He writes in his personal capacity.
The post An informed assault on the COVID-19 infodemic appeared first on Zimbabwe Situation.
Source: Police in another lockdown brutality storm | Newsday (News) POLICE brutality reared its ugly head again last week after officers deployed to enforce government’s 21-day national lockdown order severely battered a 27-year-old man from Warren Park, Harare, and fractured his hand. By Desmond Chingarande Tendai Mtombeni told NewsDay yesterday that he passed out after […]
The post Police in another lockdown brutality storm appeared first on Zimbabwe Situation.
Source: Police in another lockdown brutality storm | Newsday (News)
POLICE brutality reared its ugly head again last week after officers deployed to enforce government’s 21-day national lockdown order severely battered a 27-year-old man from Warren Park, Harare, and fractured his hand.
By Desmond Chingarande
Tendai Mtombeni told NewsDay yesterday that he passed out after the assault on Friday and only regained consciousness the following day after being admitted to a local private medical facility with the help of the Zimbabwe Association of Doctors for Human Rights.
“I am a car washer and I was visited at home by my client who wanted his car washed. He gave me US$5 and I had no change, so I decided to go to Warren Park shops to get the change,” Mtombeni said.
“While on my way, I met police officers who were in a truck. They were more than 50 in the truck.
“They stopped me and asked where I was coming from and I told them that I was looking for change. A female officer then grabbed me by the belt and told me to get into the truck.
“As I was explaining to her that I was looking for change for a client who was waiting at my home, she started beating me and her colleagues disembarked from the truck and joined in the assault. They took my Nokia mobile phone and the money and they went away with it. I sustained injuries on my head, hand and all over my body. They left me unconscious and I don’t know how I got home.”
He is now walking with the aid of crutches.
ZADHR board secretary Norman Matara told NewsDay that a CT scan on Mtombeni revealed that he had fractured his left hand.
There have been several reports of brutality by police and soldiers since the 21-day national lockdown came into effect on March 30.
One such case is of a Karoi woman who sued the police after they allegedly unleashed a dog on her after finding her preparing supper inside her yard.
Police spokesperson Assistant Commissioner Paul Nyathi said Warren Park police had no report pertaining to the incident.
“I have checked with Harare province police, who contacted the police officers on the ground at Warren Park Police, but they said there was no such report,” he said.
“If you can provide more details, we could have helped, but without a case report, it will be difficult to deal with that issue.”
However, some people purporting to be from the police intelligence department visited Mtombeni’s residence yesterday evening claiming they were investigating the assault, his family said
The post Police in another lockdown brutality storm appeared first on NewsDay Zimbabwe.
The post Police in another lockdown brutality storm appeared first on Zimbabwe Situation.
Source: Nkomo memorial lecture set for CUT | Newsday (News) THIS year’s edition of the late Vice-President Joshua Nkomo memorial lecture will be held at the Chinhoyi University of Technology on a date yet to be advised as all public gatherings have been banned in the wake of the coronavirus outbreak. BY NQOBANI NDLOVU Organisers […]
The post Nkomo memorial lecture set for CUT appeared first on Zimbabwe Situation.
Source: Nkomo memorial lecture set for CUT | Newsday (News)
THIS year’s edition of the late Vice-President Joshua Nkomo memorial lecture will be held at the Chinhoyi University of Technology on a date yet to be advised as all public gatherings have been banned in the wake of the coronavirus outbreak.
BY NQOBANI NDLOVU
Organisers of the event, the Joshua Nkomo Legacy Foundation (JNLF), yesterday dismissed social media reports that the lecture would be held at Nkomo’s Matsheumhlope home in Bulawayo on April 18.
Fliers were circulated on social media stating that the 2020 Joshua Nkomo memorial lecture would coincide with Independence Day celebrations museum with Open Society Initiative for Southern Africa (OSISA) executive director Siphosami Malunga expected to be the guest speaker.
“A staff member (at the museum) rushed to advertise the memorial lecture at the museum without consulting others.
However, as far as we know, that lecture is cancelled,” said JNLF co-ordinator Jabulani Hadebe.
“What we have agreed on is to hold this years’ lecture at the CUT, but the date has not been confirmed as yet pending the lifting of the coronavirus lockdown.”
The Joshua Nkomo lecture series was launched in 2017 to “sustain and advance the legacy and vision” of Father Zimbabwe, with the inaugural events held at Wits University in South Africa and Gwanda State University.
Hadebe said the public lectures are important to honour and highlight “the rich legacy of leadership, personal sacrifice, patriotism and national reconstruction that have been bequeathed to Zimbabwe by this great champion (Nkomo) of Zimbabwe’s national movement that culminated in independence in 1980.”
Nkomo was born on June 7, 1917 and died on July 1, 1999 at the age of 82.
The JNLF said it was also organising a Joshua Nkomo memorial youth symposium, Bulawayo outreach awards and the Joshua Nkomo centenary football challenge, whose dates are yet to be announced.
The post Nkomo memorial lecture set for CUT appeared first on NewsDay Zimbabwe.
The post Nkomo memorial lecture set for CUT appeared first on Zimbabwe Situation.